Lake Fenton, Fenton Charter Township, MI — July 1, 2025
Many longtime residents of the Fenton area are likely familiar with the history of Lake Fenton and its unique island, situated in the middle of the body of water. Once known as Long Lake, the property is steeped in Indian lore, legends of wars fought against outlaws, and tales of wealthy men laying claim to the island where they established their residence.
Once known as Bennett’s Island after a boat captain who carried passengers around the lake. Today, the 13-acre property, known as Case Island, features a number of homes and cottages where residents enjoy island living in a beautiful northern setting.
Own a Piece of Case Island
In a rare opportunity, home buyers can own a piece of Case Island. One of the premier Lake Fenton homes on the island has been listed for sale by the Lasco Real Estate Group. We won’t try to improve on their description of the residence located at 2234 Toledo Street.
“Welcome to your island oasis on highly sought-after Case’s Island in the center of Lake Fenton. Nestled on a generous .5-acre lot with prime park views, this meticulously maintained 3-bedroom, 1.5-bath home combines classic cottage charm with modern comfort. The open floor-plan layout features newer hardwood flooring throughout. The full bath is updated & features an oversized shower, a jetted soaking tub, and upgraded finishes. Enjoy all-season comfort with central air, a forced-air LP gas furnace, and a cozy wood stove–perfect for crisp Michigan evenings. Step out to the screened-in porch to look over the park area with sweeping lake views, or out to your back deck overlooking your enormous private yard. Call for private showing today! Buyers agents must take clients by boat.” Call or Text Jennifer Lasco at 248-840-6059. You Can Visit the listing page by clicking on this link.
But Hurry, this fabulous home for sale on Lake Fenton will not stay on the market for long.
Lake Fenton Facts
- 845 Acres in size
- 92ft Maximum Depth
- All Sports Lake
- 3 Miles end to end
